When to knock in Gin Rummy

Updated

Knocking is the most important decision in Gin Rummy, and it is one most beginners get wrong in one of two ways. Some knock too late and lose the hand. Others knock too soon and get undercut. This page gives you a way to decide, using the same scoring as our Gin Rummy game.

The basics of knocking

You may knock after your discard when your deadwood is 10 or less. The rest of the hand is a comparison. Your opponent shows their cards, lays off what they can onto your melds, and the two deadwood totals are compared.

  • If yours is lower, you score the difference.
  • If theirs is the same or lower, they undercut you and score 25 plus the difference.

You can find the full scoring on the Gin Rummy rules. The rest of this page is about when it is worth it.

What layoffs do

Layoffs are the part that surprises new players. After you knock, your opponent does not have to take their deadwood as it stands. If they hold a card that extends one of your melds, they may put it there and take it out of their count.

They can add to a run at either end, such as a 7♠ on your 4♠ 5♠ 6♠, or the fourth card to a set of three, such as the 7♠ on 7♣ 7♦ 7♥. They cannot lay off onto your deadwood, and they cannot lay off at all if you went gin.

In our game, this is done for you, and the best possible layoffs are chosen. That is a good reason to think about what your opponent might hold. A hand that looks safe at 8 may be undercut after layoffs.

A knock that works

You discard and hold: 7♣ 7♦ 7♥, 4♠ 5♠ 6♠, 9♦ 10♦ J♦, and K♣. The K♣ is 10 points of deadwood, so you can knock.

Your opponent’s hand is 2♥ 2♣ 2♦, 9♣ 9♥ 9♠, 7♠, Q♥, 8♣, and A♠. They lay off 7♠ on your run. That leaves Q♥, 8♣, and A♠, which are worth 10 + 8 + 1 = 19.

You win the hand and score 19 − 10 = 9 points.

A knock that backfires

Now you hold 5♥ 5♣ 5♠, 9♠ 10♠ J♠, A♦ 2♦ 3♦, and 8♣. The 8♣ is your only deadwood, worth 8, so you knock.

Your opponent holds 6♥ 7♥ 8♥, Q♣ Q♦ Q♥, 4♦, 5♦, 2♣, and 6♠. As it stands their deadwood is 4 + 5 + 2 + 6 = 17, and you look comfortable.

But both the 4♦ and the 5♦ fit on the end of your run A♦ 2♦ 3♦. They lay them off, and only 2♣ and 6♠ are left, worth 8. That is the same as your 8, so it is an undercut. They score 25 plus 0, and you score nothing.

The gap looked like 9 points and vanished with two layoffs. A knock with a small margin is risky, because layoffs eat the margin.

How big a gap do you need?

Your opponent can lay off a few cards, often one or two, and each one can be worth anything from 1 to 10 points of deadwood. So assume your opponent is a few points better than they look. These are rules of thumb, not laws:

  • Deadwood of 0 to 3. Knock. You are very hard to undercut, and waiting risks the opponent catching up.
  • Deadwood of 4 to 7. Knock if the opponent has been taking cards from the discard pile and may be well advanced, or if it is late in the hand. Otherwise, one more turn may be worth it.
  • Deadwood of 8 to 10. Be careful. Knock only when the hand is nearly over, or when your opponent seems far from ready.

Gin or knock?

Going gin pays 25 plus your opponent’s whole deadwood, and nobody can lay off. A hand with 2 points of deadwood is one card away from gin. But waiting a turn gives your opponent a turn too.

If the opponent has been drawing from the stock and discarding loose cards, they are probably not close, and you can wait for gin. If they have taken two or three discards in a row, knock now.

The undercut is worth 25 here

An undercut is worth more in our game than in many printed rules, because it carries a 25-point bonus. A knock that would have won you 5 points can cost you 25 or more. That is why a safe knock matters more than a fast one.

For general play, see the Gin Rummy strategy guide.

A few good questions

What is an undercut in Gin Rummy?

An undercut happens when you knock and your opponent finishes with the same deadwood as you or less. They score 25 points plus the difference, and you score nothing.

Can my opponent lay off cards if I go gin?

No. When you go gin, with zero deadwood, your opponent cannot lay off any cards. They only count their own deadwood.

Play Gin Rummy

More card games